Salad Week: Toughie’s Apple Salad

It’s Salad Week! What a glorious way to celebrate Spring. Once again, my blogging partners in crime and I are co-oping a food themed week and this time salads are the stars. And honestly after a big sugar-filled holiday weekend, who couldn’t use a few new salad recipes, am I right?

In our salad week discussions, the topic of retro salads came up as well as salads made with unconventional ingredients. Examples: Twinkie Salad and aspic. Does anyone even know what aspic is anymore? The retro salads of potlucks past struck a chord with me, so today I’m featuring one of my mother-in-law’s fruit salads from the 1950’s. It has a few unexpected ingredients, but they all come together beautifully to make an old-fashioned potluck favorite.

For the record, my mother-in-law is a gem. She’s spunky and funny and I love her very much. Her nickname is Toughie, and this is Toughie’s Apple Salad.

Toughie’s Apple Salad:
4 crisp apples, peeled & chopped
1 small can of crushed pineapple
1 small can of pineapple tidbits
2 eggs
1 cup sugar
2 tablespoons cornstarch
1 teaspoon yellow mustard
the juice of one fresh lemon
the juice from both cans of pineapple
1/4 cup shredded coconut
1/2 cup finely shredded sharp cheddar cheese

To start, peel and dice the apples and toss them into a large mixing bowl. Open the cans of pineapple and drain the juice, reserving it for the custard dressing; toss the drained pineapple into the bowl with the apples.

In a saucepan, whisk together the eggs, sugar, cornstarch, mustard, lemon juice and the juice from both cans of pineapple. Cook over medium heat, whisking often to prevent lumps, until the mixture becomes thick and bubbly. Remove from the heat and allow to cool completely. If you’re in a hurry, pour the custard into a bowl and pop it into the fridge to chill.

Once the custard is cool, pour it over the fruit and stir to combine.

Pour the mixture into your serving dish, then sprinkle the coconut and cheese over the top. Serve cold as a dessert salad.

My thoughts: Yes, it’s weird to put a little yellow mustard in a fruit custard, but the surprising thing is you don’t taste mustard in the finished product. It gives it a bright little tang like lemon zest would. So while it sounds weird, don’t leave it out. It really adds a zing. Cheese also throws some people off when they see this fruit salad. Is it necessary? Probably not. There’s really not enough of it to have a strong impact. What it does do is give you a nice contrast between the sweet of the fruit and the sharp cheddar when you take a bite. And speaking of sweet, this custard is very sweet. I was a good girl this time and stuck to the recipe as Toughie intended it, but the next time I make it I’ll be cutting the sugar down to a 1/2 cup or maybe even a 1/4 cup. If you prefer less sugar and more natural sweetness in your fruit salad, I recommend you do the same.

Now, on to the rest of Salad Week. Don’t forget to visit my lovely friends throughout the week as they share a few introductory salads to whet your appetite. Then on Saturday April 14th, we’ll all be posting salads in a big Salad Week Extravaganza – much like the grand finale of a fireworks display. In addition, there will be a linky party over at Allison’s place so you can not only see all of our salads from the week, but you can add your own favorites, as well.

Salad Week bloggers include:
Allison – Decadent Philistines Save the World
Jeanne – Inside NanaBread’s Head (hey, that’s me!)
Lauren – Climbing Grier Mountain
Kat – Tenaciously Yours
Kirsten – Comfortably Domestic
Megan – Wanna Be A Country Cleaver
Madelyn – La Petite Pancake
Monica – The Grommom
Carrie – Bakeaholic Mama



Filed under Blogger Collaborations, Food & Recipes

16 responses to “Salad Week: Toughie’s Apple Salad

  1. laurengrier

    Holla for Salad Week! My curiosity level is at an 11/10! Cheese with pineapple? Who would of thunk? I love old recipes because they had jack squat for ingredients back then, but ended up making some pretty tasty treats. Can’t wait to try!

    • Cooks from my mother-in-law’s generation were nothing if not resourceful. Yes, cheese with pineapple sounds funky, but one of the hottest casseroles of the time was a baked pineapple casserole with a cheese topping. My motto is ‘be adventurous!’ with a side of ‘don’t knock it until you try it’. There’s a whole realm of retro salads out there just waiting to be rediscovered. Who’s with me?!?

  2. Kat

    Oh my gosh, this is like totally out of my retro salad cookbook and gives me some hope that whatever it is that I concoct for Saturday will actually be edible!

    All I can say is Prepare Yourself Emotionally. If it doesn’t involve Aspic, it may be molded or frozen.

  3. Pingback: Hey! It’s Me…Over Here! « Comfortably Domestic

  4. Pingback: An Easter Story « Comfortably Domestic

  5. Jeanne, I have the same baking dish. I <3 old Fire King stuff. And YAY for Salad Week. I gotta try this I love apples and cheese. YUM.

  6. Pingback: Salad Week: Party Salad | Tenaciously Yours,

  7. Pingback: Country Cleaver » Chicken Mole Salad for Salad Week

  8. Pingback: Salad Week: Simple Caesar Salad « Comfortably Domestic

  9. Pingback: Friday Food Round-Up! | Tenaciously Yours,

  10. Joanne

    Toughie’s Apple salad looks good

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s