I put the Ice Cream in Cake Week

Wahoo! It’s Cake Week! I love these collaborative cooking weeks. I get borderline giddy with anticipation to see what my friends will be making. Those girls never fail to impress. For my contribution to Cake Week, I chose the ice cream cake category. Why? Because I like to shake things up, and because I promised myself that I would keep trying new things as my carry-over mantra from 2011. Hence, I give you my very first ice cream cake. Or cakes. I made them individual serving size, and here’s how it all went down.

Ice cream wrapped in a chocolate cake hug & smothered in more chocolate.

What you’ll need to pull this off:
1 cake mix + the oil, eggs & water to go with it
2 pints of your favorite ice cream (I chose two flavors)
2 bottles of Magic Shell chocolate ice cream coating
Candy melts, nonpareils, or other decorative touches
Heart-shaped cookie cutter (or round, square or other)
Parchment paper & various baking pans

1. Starting with a dark chocolate fudge cake mix (yes, a cake mix), I mixed it according to the package directions except for one small thing. I substituted 1/4 cup of Hershey’s Special Dark chocolate syrup for 1/4 cup of the water. Because nothing compliments chocolate like more chocolate.

2. I covered a sheet cake pan with parchment paper and spread the cake batter in a thin layer (about 1/4″). That sounds thin, but the batter puffs to about 1/2″ when it’s done. I baked it at 350F until the cake was slightly springy to the touch and a toothpick came out clean. Once out of the oven, I let it cool to room temperature, then slid the entire sheet pan into the freezer for at least one hour so the cake would be firm enough to cut without falling apart.

3. Using a heart-shaped cookie cutter, I cut the cake into 8 hearts (each about 4″ wide) and placed them back in the freezer while I prepared the ice cream. Note: to make 4 individual-size ice cream cakes, you’ll need 8 cake cutouts and 4 ice cream cutouts in whichever shape you choose.

4. For the ice cream layer, I selected a pint of Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia frozen yogurt and a pint of Ben & Jerry’s Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream. I softened both in the microwave for 30-40 seconds, stirred to loosen them up, then poured each pint into a parchment-lined pan. I spread the ice cream into a 1/2″ thick layer and placed both pans back into the freezer to firm up.

I 'heart' cake and ice cream.

5. Once the ice cream was firm, I used the same cookie cutter to cut the ice cream into heart shapes. I then stacked an ice cream slice onto 4 hearts and topped them with another cake heart. I pressed ever so lightly to set the layers together, but not so hard as to cause the ice cream to squish out. I popped it all back into the freezer to firm up again. As you can see, these take very little work, but a bit of time as each stage goes back into the freezer to set up.

6. Once the ice cream cakes were good and cold, I removed them one at a time and covered them in Magic Shell. Ever used Magic Shell? It’s liquid chocolate in a bottle that sets up into a hard chocolate shell when it hits cold ice cream and it makes a lovely, smooth coating for ice cream cakes. Again, they go back into the freezer for 10 minutes, or until the Magic Shell is firm.

7. To decorate, I melted pink candy melts over a double boiler, then scraped it into a baggie, snipped off the corner of the bag, and quickly piped decorative touches on the cakes. Some got crisscrossed hash marks (as seen above) and some got piped pink hearts. The hearts got a liberal sprinkling of pink nonpareils because they look so pretty. And what girl doesn’t love pastel nonpareils?

Pink candy melts and nonpareils make everything prettier.

8. Once they’re done, store your ice cream cakes in an air-tight container in your freezer. To serve, simply plate about 5 minutes before serving. Well, I say 5 minutes because I live in Houston and it’s always warm down here. If you live in a colder climate, set them out about 10 minutes before serving.

The great thing about this simple version of ice cream cake is that it’s limited only by your imagination and the selection of cake mixes and ice cream sold at your neighborhood store. Pick your favorite ice cream, then pair it with a complimentary cake mix, and you’ll be off to the races. Strawberry cake with banana split ice cream? Why not? Fudge cake with coffee ice cream? Sounds divine! Butter cake with pecan praline? When should I come over? Now go forth and bake, my minions. Bake and slather cake layers in ice cream. You’ll be surprised at how easy these are to make.

Don’t forget to check out this week’s posts from my fellow bloggers:

MondayFilled Cupcakes from Kirsten at Comfortably Domestic
TuesdayMolten Lava Cake from Mads at La Petite Pancake
Wednesday – Ice Cream Cakelettes from NanaBread (hey, that’s me!)
ThursdayPetite Bundt Cakes by Kat at Tenaciously Yours
FridayPupcakes from Allison at Decadent Philistines Save the World
Saturday – Ombre Rose Cake from Megan at Wanna Be A Country Cleaver

Now for the really fun part. Kirsten, our fearless leader, is celebrating Cake Week with a linky party. If you have a favorite cake recipe you’ve blogged about, click here to link up and join the fun. If you’re more of a cake lover than cake blogger, drop by! It’s a great way to add new recipes to your repertoire. Just click any link photo to open the blog page and view the recipe. It’s like finding a collection of cake recipe cards, but more fun and with better photos!

Now if you’ll excuse me, this girl’s got a date with an ice cream cake.

If you need me, I'll be hiding in a closet so I don't have to share. Sorry, honey.



Filed under Blogger Collaborations, Food & Recipes

20 responses to “I put the Ice Cream in Cake Week

  1. I love this idea! The making of the cakelettes would make for a great party activity for kids. You could make the cake part ahead of time and then give kids several ice cream choices for their cakelette, and let them assemble and decorate theirs accordingly. Thanks for sharing!

    • You’re right. This would be a great activity for kids at a party. You could easily bake the cake in advance. You could even have the ice cream frozen on a sheet pan so it’s ready to cut, as well. The kids could then cut their cake pieces and ice cream pieces and stack them all together. If Magic Shell is out of the picture for any reason, chocolate chips or candy coating pieces work just as well. Just melt and whisk until lump-free just before decorating. Thanks for the comment and the visit, Island Mom. And thanks for supporting Cake Week!

  2. Big Sis

    Cool, but what I want to know is where did you get that fabric you have on the table??? I want it!!! It would go in my house so wonderfully!

    • Great response, Megan. These are definitely un-hinge worthy. Ice cream and cake just go together. Like mashed potatoes & gravy. Peas & carrots. Peanut butter & jelly. Ricky & Lucy. Butter & more butter. They’re so easy to make, there’s just really no reason not to.

  3. Kat

    I can’t decide if I’m more excited about the fact that these are individual cakelettes so that you don’t have to share your plunder, or the fact that pink candy melts and nonpareils are present. Even though this is counter-intuitive, this would be a great winter recipe because Minnesotans have been known to use their garages as auxiliary freezers during the holidays, etc. to get things to chill/set when space is at a premium.

    • Whoa! I can’t even imagine a place cold enough to store ice cream in the garage in the winter. But then, I can’t imagine living any place where the snow gets so deep you have to put bike flags on the bumpers so the snow plows know where the cars are. Uhhhhhhhh…I’m trying to picture it, but I just can’t. On the flip side, I can fry an egg on my back porch in the summer. Hypothetically, of course. :)

  4. Pingback: The kind of day… | Tenaciously Yours,

  5. Pingback: Cake Week: From-Scratch Funfetti | Tenaciously Yours,

  6. Pingback: Cake Week, Day 3: Magic Ice Cream Cake « Comfortably Domestic

  7. Pingback: Cake Week, Day 3: Magic Ice Cream Cake « Comfortably Domestic

  8. Pingback: Cake Week: Molten Lava Cake! | La Petite Pancake

  9. Whoa. Talk about delish.

    And you always make it look so easy and like anyone can do it. Which makes me start thinking very confident of myself.

    Obviously, you don’t know I’ve stored shoes in my oven before.

    • These really and truly are easy to make, Carrie. You’ll only need to move your shoes for the cake baking part. Unless you’re also storing shoes in your freezer, and then we’ll definitely need to talk.

  10. Pingback: Friday Food Round-Up! | Tenaciously Yours,

  11. Pingback: Country Cleaver » A Bouquet of Roses – Just for You

  12. Pingback: Everything is Coming Up Roses: Cake Week Day 6 « Comfortably Domestic

  13. Pingback: An Act of Improvement | Tenaciously Yours,

  14. routid

    A so lovely Cake !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s